PDF

Keywords

derogation clauses, emergency powers, human rights, COVID-19, Article 15 ECHR, state of exception, Council of Europe.

Abstract

In many legal systems, the state of emergency is a well-known and recognized legal instrument and allows a certain degree of derogation from human rights standards. However, in some cases emergencies provide governments with convenient reasons for strengthening their powers, weakening democratic institutions, and repressing political opponents.The magnitude and severity of the COVID-19 pandemic has clearly risen to the level of danger to public health and has given rise to a wide range of legal responses across the Council of Europe States, which can justify restrictions on certain rights. However, when derogation clauses are used, there is a risk of going beyond the principle of proportionality, which may bring to the abusive exercise of power. Nevertheless, while dealing with COVID-19 Pandemic formal declaration of a State of emergency and the notification of derogations under the Human Rights Treaty may have a positive impact on the constraining of emergency powers within prescribed limits.

PDF

References

1.Alan Greene “Emergency powers in a time of pandemic”. Bristol University Press 2020.

2.Alan Greene “Permanent States of Emergency and the Rule of Law: Constitutions in an Age of Crisis”. Hart Publishing, 2018.

3.Armin von Bogdandy, Pedro A. Villarreal “International Law on Pandemic Response: A First Stocktaking in Light of the Coronavirus Crisis”. MPIL Research Paper Series 2020-07.

4.Audrey Lebret COVID-19 pandemic and derogation to human rights. Advance Access Publication 4 May 2020. P.8. Article Downloaded from:

https://academic.oup.com/jlb/article/7/1/lsaa015/5828398on 02 October 2020 [last access: November 23, 2020]

5.Christopher Michaelsen “Permanent Legal Emergencies and the Derogation Clause in International Human Rights Treaties: A Contradiction?” p.p.287-315 in Post 9/11 and the State of Permanent Legal Emergency. Security and Human Rights in Countering Terrorism. 2012.

6.Cornelius Hirsch “Europe’s coronavirus lockdown measures compared”. 2020.https://www.politico.eu/article/europes-coronavirus-lockdown-measures-compared/ [last access: October 31, 2020]

7.COVID-19 Symposium: To Derogate or Not to Derogate?http://opiniojuris.org/2020/04/06/covid-19-symposium-to-derogate-or-not-to-derogate/April 6, 2020 [last access: November 15, 2020]

8.Emilie M. Hafner-Burton et al. “Emergency and Escape: Explaining Derogations from Human Rights Treaties”, in 65 International Organization 673-707 (2011).

9.Gerald L. Neuman “Constitutional Derogation in Positive Human Rights Regime”, in Evan J. Criddle, Human Rights in Emergencies (CUP, 2026).

10.William A. Schabas, The European Convention on Human Rights: A Commentary (OUP 2015).